Tim Burton has a diversity problem. It’s no secret that Burton’s many films have predominantly white casts, which is why Samuel L. Jackson’s big supporting role in Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children is so surprising. Jackson appears to be the first non-white actor with a major role in a Burton film. He is also, however, the only non-white actor in the movie. When asked by Bustle about the film’s diversity, or lack thereof, Burton gave this lackluster answer: “Things either call for things, or they don’t.”
Given his answer, it’s clear that Burton has never bothered to wonder why his films lack diversity. He seems to suffer from the same view that plagues Hollywood: unless a character is written with a specific ethnicity in mind, the default is that said character is white. And even if the character’s ethnicity is specified, in Hollywood, it can always be changed to be white (just look at Scarlett Johansson in Ghost in the Shell). But Burton’s answer also suggests one very important thing — that Miss Peregrine’s does not call for diversity and that it couldn’t possibly warrant an interracial cast. Well, Burton, you’re wrong; and to prove it, here are just a few non-white actors that could have been cast in Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children. (Note: gender and age of characters reflect those in the film, not the book.)
Gugu Mbatha-Raw as Miss Peregrine
Gugu Mbatha-Raw has the perfect blend of warmth and mystery to play Miss Peregrine.
Tony Revolori As Jake
Tony Revolori (The Grand Budapest Hotel) has what it takes to play an outsider like Jake.
Amandla Stenberg as Emma Bloom
Amandla Stenberg’s grace would be perfect for Emma.
Quvenzhane? Wallis as Fiona Fruanfeld
Quvenzhane? Wallis is basically magic, so playing a peculiar child shouldn’t be too difficult.
Marsai Martin as Claire Densmore
Marsai Martin is so sweet on Blackish, you’d never guess she could have a mouth on the back of her head like Claire.
Ian Chen as Hugh Apiston
Ian Chen (Fresh Off the Boat) is adorable and hilarious. That is all.
Yara Shahidi as Olive Abroholos Elephanta
Yara Shahidi (also of Blackish) is a star on the rise, and she’d make a perfect Olive.
Neel Sethi as Horace Somnusson
Neel Sethi (The Jungle Book) would make an adorable Horace — imagine him in a top hat.
Keiynan Lonsdale as Enoch O’Connor
Keiynan Lonsdale (The Flash) is sweet enough to fit in with the kids, yet edgy enough to play Enoch.
Lucy Liu As Dr. Golan
Dr. Golan was gender-swapped in the film (she’s played by Allison Janney), and Lucy Lui would also have made a great baddie.
Leave a Comment